CO129-216 - Governor Sir Bowen - 1884 [5-6] — Page 33

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

32

of Hong Kong (Mr O'Malley) to transmit the enclosed Memorandum, on those parts of that despatch which regard the opinion previously given by him on certain points connected with the constitution of the Legislative Council of this Colony.

2. It will be seen that the intimation as to whether the decision over-ruling the advice of the Attorney General adheres to his former opinion, I should mention that it has been remarked here that the despatch now under reply (No. 51) contains no indication whether the Law Officer of the Crown in this Colony was taken on the advice of the Law Officers of the Crown in England, or only on the advice of the Colonial Department in Downing Street; and that, with all due respect for that Department, the opinion of the Law Officers of the Crown or legal points would necessarily carry far more weight, and would be regarded as definitely settling...

Edit History

2026-05-24 11:04:52 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
32 of Hong Kong (Mr O'Malley) to transmit the enclosed Memorandum, on those parts of that despatch which regard the opinion previously given by him on certain points connected with the constitution of the Legislative Council of this Colony. 2. It will be seen that the intimation as to whether the decision over-ruling the advice of the Attorney General adheres to his former opinion, I should mention that it has been remarked here that the despatch now under reply (No. 51) contains no indication whether the Law Officer of the Crown in this Colony was taken on the advice of the Law Officers of the Crown in England, or only on the advice of the Colonial Department in Downing Street; and that, with all due respect for that Department, the opinion of the Law Officers of the Crown or legal points would necessarily carry far more weight, and would be regarded as definitely settling...
Baseline (Original)
32 of Hong Kong (Mr O'Malley) to trausmit the enclosed Memorandum, on those parts of that despatch which regard the opission previously given by him on certain points Connected with the constitution of the Legislative Council of Colony- 2. this It will be seen that the intivation as to whether the Enclosure decision over - ruling the advice of U Attorney Gecceral adheres to his former opinion, I should mention that it has been remarked here that the despatch now under reply (Nr. 51) contains no ~ the Law Officer of the Crown in this Colony was taken ou the advice of the Law Officers of the Crown in England, or only on the advice, the Colonial ~ :ce of the Department in Downing Street ; and that, with all due respect for that Department, the opinion of the Law Officers of the Crown or legal pouts would necessarily carry far more weight, and would be regarded as definitely intimation Settling
2026-05-24 11:04:52 · Baseline
View content

32

of Hong Kong (Mr O'Malley) to

trausmit the enclosed Memorandum,

on those parts of

that despatch

which regard the opission previously given by him on certain points

Connected with the constitution

of the Legislative Council of

Colony-

2.

this

It will be seen that the

intivation as to whether the

Enclosure

decision over

- ruling the advice

of

U

Attorney Gecceral adheres to his former opinion, I should mention

that it has been remarked here

that the despatch

now under

reply (Nr. 51) contains no ~

the Law Officer of the Crown in

this Colony

was taken ou

the

advice of the Law Officers of the Crown in England, or only on

the advice, the Colonial ~

:ce of the

Department in Downing Street ; and that, with all due respect

for that Department, the opinion

of the Law Officers of the Crown

or

legal pouts would necessarily

carry far

more weight, and

would be regarded as definitely

intimation

Settling

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.